So without further ado, the Game of the Year for me was Atelier Meruru and the Soundtrack of the Year was Rave Racer, an old Arcade game with a killer soundtrack.
EDIT: And I’ll add this. I don’t know if anyone else plays flash games, but the best flash game soundtrack from the year, as far as I can think, was for Knightmare Tower (http://www.kongregate.com/games/JuicyBeast/knightmare-tower). Really unexpected stuff in there for the genre that counterbalanced the repetitiveness of the game.
As far as Game of the Year… kind of shocking really, but I’ll go with SMITE from Hi-Rez Software. The music in the game is nothing to write home about, fine for the first 20 hours or so of multiplayer, but I’ve been on Spotify and internet radio streams for about a month while playing it now, which isn’t such a bad thing as I don’t get much time to listen to music much anymore. Runner-up would be Halo 4. Biggest disappointment is by far Mass Effect 3.