I may be new to this board but in the last two weeks I did an expanded version for myself. But first of all I�d like to write about my findings about these recording sessions and some other tracks. It�s interesting what you can discover when you�re attempting to remaster a crappy source like this one. Well, here it goes:
The tracks "Stardate 7412.6", "Warp .8", "Stardate
7413.4/warp .9", "Stardate 7414.1" which can be found on some of the "complete" releases seem to come from the movie itself, either cleverly edited or extracted, I don�t know how. I tried to do the same but was unsucessful. On three of them you can hear background noises from the Enterprise-bridge during low volume sequences. Furthermore, even in their lossless state there is nothing happening beyond 12 kHz (even mp3 reaches 16 kHz) so they very well can be treated as lossy. Even worse, they were de-noised with a crappy de-noiser. Giveaways: flanging effects that normally can be found in bad lossy encoders. Here they are caused by badly configured de-noising but it still sounds like shit if I may say so. The archive with the additional lossless tracks that was posted here a few days ago is also mostly lossy quality - nothing happening beyond 12 kHz.
Now to the truly lossless versions: I don�t know where I got this but I have a version here that has every other track that is known so far in lossless quality.
Where does this lossless version come from? Well, it comes from several cassette tapes. The strong noise is a giveaway, also the azimuth problems. Even worse, the cassettes have been stored at a hot place (probably in a car during summer) so the tape itself has bended - now the tape slides uncontrollably over the head at times. This is very noticable. The tapes itself were recorded from the analogue mastertapes. As one may know, Star Trek was recording with three different techniques: analogue tape, on optical film and on digital tape. For the cassette bootleg the analogue tape was used as a source. Some tracks (for example "A good Start") have the same errors as the one on the official CD from 1998. Anyway, these tapes were recorded with a soundcard and therefore transferred to the PC. These transfers subsequently leaked.
I used these transfers to create my own version. For years, I desperately wanted to "remaster" them. But every de-noising attempt failed miserably, the noise is just too high. But three weeks ago I finally figured out what has been wrong all the time and what no one had figured out till then: the cassette tapes used to make these transfers were encoded with Dolby Noise Reduction! I don�t know if many people around still know Dolby as a noise reduction system (that�s how they came into prominence), just let me tell you this much: a Dolby-encoded tapes needs to be decoded with Dolby again. If it is not decoded then you�ll have the sound of the Star-Trek-boot. Now that I knew this I also knew how to do an improved version.
In short, I created a remastered version. Before you get your hopes up: it doesn�t sound that good, the official CD still sounds much much better. The bootleg tracks still have some fast wow-and-flutter and still sound a bit awkward. But the noise is almost completely gone and the overall sound is much closer to the officially released stuff. I also corrected the frequency response and the stereo separation, did a lot of editing, hell, I even ended up restoring the original dynamic (difference between low and loud volumes) by hand for every bootleg-based track since this had been compromised by the tape transfer. The overall frequency response is now much closer to the already released tracks. Completely off were the alternate tracks with the early version of the main theme: they sounded horrible, as if they were recorded for a different movie (i�m talking about the sound, not the music). Now they also sound close to the rest.
In fact, the official release also has some problems: sonically the tracks "Floating Office", "V'Ger speaks" and "A good Start" don�t fit in. They have much less high frequency energy compared to the rest of the tracks. Very obviously the producers for the 1998 version also had some crappy master available. They also attempted to de-noise the music, in case of the first half of "V'Ger speaks" they failed. Just listen to it via headphone, compare it to other tracks and you�ll know what I mean.
Anyway, here is the tracklist for my release. Oh, don�t be surprised, I erased some tracks because I really didn�t need two versions of the "Main Title".
Ouverture Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 01/40 1979 Soundtrack 01 Ouverture.wv
Main Title Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 02/40 1979 Soundtrack 02 Main Title.wv
Klingon Battle Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 03/40 1979 Soundtrack 03 Klingon Battle.wv
Total Logic Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 04/40 1979 Soundtrack 04 Total Logic.wv
Floating Office Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 05/40 1979 Soundtrack 05 Floating Office.wv
The Enterprise Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 06/40 1979 Soundtrack 06 The Enterprise.wv
Transporter Malfunction Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 07/40 1979 Soundtrack 07 Transporter Malfunction.wv
Crew Briefing Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 08/40 1979 Soundtrack 08 Crew Briefing.wv
Destruction of Epsilon 9 Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 09/40 1979 Soundtrack 09 Destruction of Epsilon 9.wv
Pre-Launch Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 10/40 1979 Soundtrack 10 Pre-Launch.wv
Leaving Drydock Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 11/40 1979 Soundtrack 11 Leaving Drydock.wv
No Goodbyes Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 12/40 1979 Soundtrack 12 No Goodbyes.wv
Spock's Arrival Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 13/40 1979 Soundtrack 13 Spock's Arrival.wv
Red Alert Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 14/40 1979 Soundtrack 14 Red Alert.wv
The Cloud Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 15/40 1979 Soundtrack 15 The Cloud.wv
V'Ger Flyover Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 16/40 1979 Soundtrack 16 Vejur Flyover.wv
Force Field Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 17/40 1979 Soundtrack 17 Force Field (Film Version).wv
Micro Exam Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 18/40 1979 Soundtrack 18 Micro Exam.wv
Games Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 19/40 1979 Soundtrack 19 Games.wv
Thruster Suit Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 20/40 1979 Soundtrack 20 Thruster Suit.wv
Spock Walk Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 21/40 1979 Soundtrack 21 Spock Walk.wv
V'Ger signals the Creator Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 22/40 1979 Soundtrack 22 V'Ger signals the Creator.wv
Systems inoperative Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 23/40 1979 Soundtrack 23 Systems Inoperative.wv
Hidden Information Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 24/40 1979 Soundtrack 24 Hidden Information.wv
Inner Workings Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 25/40 1979 Soundtrack 25 Inner Workings.wv
Voyager 6! Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 26/40 1979 Soundtrack 26 Voyager 6!.wv
V'Ger speaks Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 27/40 1979 Soundtrack 27 Vejur Speaks.wv
The Meld Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 28/40 1979 Soundtrack 28 The Meld.wv
A good Start Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 29/40 1979 Soundtrack 29 A Good Start.wv
End Title Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 30/40 1979 Soundtrack 30 End Title.wv
Ilia's Theme Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 31/40 1979 Soundtrack 31 Ilia's Theme.wv
Main Title (Take 1) Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 32/40 1979 Soundtrack 32 Main Title (Take 1).wv
The Enterprise (Alternate) Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 33/40 1979 Soundtrack 33 The Enterprise (Alternate).wv
Leaving Drydock (Alternate) Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 34/40 1979 Soundtrack 34 Leaving Drydock (Alternate).wv
Spock's Arrival (Alternate) Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 35/40 1979 Soundtrack 35 Spock's Arrival (Alternate).wv
The Force Field (Alternate) Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 36/40 1979 Soundtrack 36 The Force Field.wv
Games (Alternate) Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 37/40 1979 Soundtrack 37 Games (Alternate).wv
Inner Workings (Alternate) Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 38/40 1979 Soundtrack 38 Inner Workings (Alternate).wv
End Title (Alternate) Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 39/40 1979 Soundtrack 39 End Title (Alternate).wv
Ilia's Theme (Alternate) Jerry Goldsmith Star Trek: The Motion Picture (DeLuxe Edition) 40/40 1979 Soundtrack 40 Ilia's Theme (Alternate).wv
BTW, I did every processing step in 32 Bit and 192 kHz. I ended up with masters in 32/96 which can be exported to almost any format - I�ll do this as soon as I�ve designed a cover. I mean, if anyone is interested in this. Remember, everything is lossless (except the "Ouverture" which comes from the DVD and was remixed by me to sound as close as possible to everything else). And - as I�ve said before - I erased one or two tracks for redundancy reasons, they absolutely made no sense at all. I also edited some tracks together ("Inner Workings" and "Voyager 6!") but they still flow like they are one. One some tracks I changed the flow, "Total Logic" doesn�t blend into "Floating Office" anymore.
Anyway, interested? :)