Whenever I try to access this site I get the message "STOP USING THE IP FRUITS" and can't access the threads I had bookmarked. What the heck does this mean?

it means you bookmarked them using the ip, not the actual site address.

I haven't had to use the new IP even once.

New server seems to be aces, Sarah <33333

Whenever I try to access this site I get the message "STOP USING THE IP FRUITS" and can't access the threads I had bookmarked. What the heck does this mean?

following on from sarah, change the ip address in your bookmarks to "forums.ffshrine.org" and it will work. eg instead of http://the.ip.address/showthread.php?t=number, use http:// forums.ffshrine.org/showthread.php?t=number.