For those of you who have played both, I would like to know which one you liked more and why. Nothing fancy.

I, personally, am on the fence. The original was longer -- a lot longer -- but wasn't nearly as scary as the sequel, in my opinion. Also, in the original, there was actually an explanation as to why there are all these monsters. The sequel gives no reason, it just has better monsters than the original.

For me Silent Hill 2 isn't too scary.I like Silent Hill 1, it's much better than Silent Hill 2(the story, not the grapichs)

Get SH2. It's just as atmospheric and scary as it's predecessor but of better quality.

I'd say that SH2 is very boring not Like SH(SCARY).

It's only has good grapichs on it:D

Same :D .I think SH is much better than SH2,expecially the monster:cool:

I thought they were both good but the scariest place in 1 would have to be the school (dark hallways with little zombie children.. eep lol) and 2 would have to be the prison.:eek:

Definitley Silent Hill. I've never played SH2, but I know it doesn't have Harry Mason in it. And Harry rules...:D