Let me start by saying I have absolutely no problem with the forum setting whatever conditions it wants for what can or cannot be shared. And I have no issues with bans for people who share inappropriate music, especially repeat offenders.
However,
Actually the site does mention RE OSTs are prohibited from being posted or even requested on this (
Thread 214356) stickied thread.
Read it twice, and I can find no mention of anything about requests, or consequences of requests,
Also, should we really point out that no requests of forbidden material are allowed, like we're speaking to fucking brats, or even toddlers?
Yes, yes you should. It is a completely reasonable assumption that if you can't have the links, you can't request the links. But it is also obvious that if you can't share the links you can't share the links privately. That is correctly mentioned on the FAQ. It's two more words in the description.
Since the forbidden list is subject to change, for me, there is a distinction between asking for something you can't have, and sending something you can't provide. Personally, I think a first warning, with reason given, and a ban on the second offense might be better.
I agree that Shriners are their own worst enemy, and that systems seem to exist to be abused, but a tweak might be useful.
JonC
---------- Post added at 01:55 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:47 PM ----------
Additional note, I access the Shrine by checking new posts only. Consequently, I don't believe I ever see updates of the forbidden list. Fortunately, I never make requests.
Anyhoo, it may also be useful to make a separate new post to indicate when the ban list changes, so people like me, who only check new posts, see that the list has been updated.