ribonucleic
07-16-2014, 03:28 AM
The debate about Capricorn One is not about its quality; nobody can effectively argue that the score isn't tremendously effective. But the two different recordings that Goldsmith produced of the score are worlds apart and thus open the doors for a debate that happens surprisingly infrequently in regards to this era in film music.
As was customary at the time, Goldsmith recorded the score for Capricorn One in late 1977 at MGM's studios in Los Angeles and then took his manuscripts to London, where he rearranged several pieces, beefed them up significantly, and re-recorded 35 minutes with the National Philharmonic Orchestra for the LP album release. Only in a few cases in the Bronze Age, such as with John Williams' The Fury, is there such a dramatic difference between the film and album recordings that questions about why the album arrangement wasn't used in the film can be raised. Purists and the most veteran collectors will refer to this discussion as rubbish, because they often accept the intent and functionality of the two types of recordings without such debate. With Capricorn One, though, you have an outstanding composition that works in the film, but the MGM version is so sparse compared to the London recording that it's difficult not to be curious about how Goldsmith's more symphonic rendering would have impacted the picture. Certainly, some of the effectiveness of the film version exists because of what some would call the avant garde constructs and instrumental choices. There is sense of harsh, raw energy and a feeling of the inevitable that Goldsmith infuses in the MGM recording that is undeniably scary. His title theme is built on top of an extremely memorable, jagged ostinato (of near-octave hopping, an obvious choice for corruption) for deep brass, percussion, timpani, drums, bells, and xylophone and serves as the identity for NASA's treachery and, more specifically, the almost life-like helicopters that pursue the astronauts at the climax of the story. Goldsmith split the string section into two, placing them in equal halves on either side of the ensemble and forcing them into combat with another when performing this ostinato, and the effect is quite menacing in its overbearing, chopping tone. The early sequences in the film extensively employ fragments of this ostinato to underline the mechanized nature of the plot. By the end of the film, all the audience needs to hear is two or three notes in this rhythmic figure to know that something unfortunate is about to happen on screen. The secondary theme in the film is one of romance for the primary astronaut's family ("Kay's Theme") and it is this yearning, tragic idea for strings, harp, and piano that only slightly occupies the soundscape until its triumphant performance in "The Celebration." Goldsmith merges the two themes in the end titles cue (and consequent concert arrangement) with fantastic success, though the score never really loses touch with the brutality of the relentless NASA theme.
As heard in the film, Goldsmith's MGM recording uses a smaller orchestra (but still imbalanced in its shifting of strings and emphasis of low brass) and electronics in sparse fashion for most of the narrative. It isn't a score of sustained action material; early scenes use very quiet, but ominous fragments of the ostinato to great effect. The few action bursts, along with the opening and closing titles, suffice in their brutality but do so without much resounding depth. The secondary family theme is equally sparse in its rendering until the end. It's not surprising, upon examining the tone of the MGM recording, that Goldsmith sought to really enhance the album version through not only a rearrangement of the action material into longer variants (and adding a concluding major key note at the end of the title theme), but also the replacement of the synthesizers (for the most part) with a larger orchestral ensemble. The resulting performance in London gives this score incredible power, offering the kind of depth that the MGM version badly lacked. The assembled "Break Out" cue, despite a few awkward splices of the master tape for the LP, is among Goldsmith's most ambitious and satisfying, and the "Main Title" is a classic piece. So here's where we get back to the perplexing question: would the album arrangement have better serviced the film? It's superior in every performance aspect and the sound quality is vastly improved. Purists, once again, would dismiss this issue. But the brutality of the composition is retained in the London recording, and the more powerful sound is arguably appropriate for the level of treachery on display. In short, the London recording might have enhanced the film even more than the MGM version, especially if the spirit of the un-rerecorded early portions was kept intact. The LP album performance... is a very strong presentation and will be best for nearly all listeners. True fans of the score will be interested in Intrada Records' limited and remastered 2005 release of the entire 53 minutes of the MGM recording. While a fascinating listening experience, the film version of Capricorn One simply can't compete with the album recording. - Filmtracks
ALBUM VERSION (Collector's Choice - 2009)
1. Main Title (2:47)
2. Bedtime Story (3:01)
3. Docking (2:55)
4. No Water (2:26)
5. The Message (4:33)
6. Breakout (3:13)
7. Kay's Theme (3:17)
8. The Station (3:30)
9. The Snake (3:37)
10. The Long Climb (3:53)
11. The Letter (2:52)
12. The Celebration (3:04)
Total - 39:08
FILM VERSION (Intrada - 2005)
1. Main Title (1:12)
2. Abort 1 (1:30)
3. Abort 2 (0:32)
4. Capricorn Control (0:25)
5. Mars (1:18)
6. Docking (2:47)
7. Working Overtime (0:43)
8. We Have Landed (0:58)
9. The Message (3:51)
10. Kay's Theme (Trio Source)/Elliot is Missing (3:38)
11. The Letter (2:54)
12. Break Out (5:04)
13. The Desert (0:28)
14. Bedtime Story (2:32)
15. The Helicopters (1:04)
16. Hide and Seek (1:22)
17. No Water (2:45)
18. Flare No. 1 (0:26)
19. The Long Climb/Flare No. 2 (3:51)
20. The Snake (3:32)
21. To Bru from Kay (1:46)
22. The Station (5:28)
23. The Celebration (1:40)
24. End Title (2:40)
Bonus Tracks:
25. Fanfare Source (0:11)
26. Breakout (LP Imitation) (3:04)
Total - 56:32
Please PM for link.
