I was banned for no reason. (Zac2uzumaki)

�No reason was specified� That�s all there was in the message. :/
Was it because I requested RE2 ost? I wasn�t aware that was forbidden to ask till a fellow member told me. No where in the request section says anything about what we can or cannot request. I apologize but again I didn�t know. I only feel bad because I won�t be able to update any of my links posted.

Actually the site does mention RE OSTs are prohibited from being posted or even requested on this (Thread 214356) stickied thread. There is a no tolerance policy in regards to posting links for music on this list as it’s your responsibility to read the forum policies in such threads and be aware of what you can and can’t do here.

So speaking as a moderator of this site I’m sorry to say your ban is justified.

Well shouldn’t that be added it too? It Says nothing about requesting. Specially on the requesting area. Also, you people simply ignored the other RE threads found on this forum?

Well I had a good run on this site.

Your attempt at "attacking" moderation is kind of pathetic, but I didn’t expect anything better. Threads not in compliance with the rules get dealt with as we spot them, moderators are human beings, after all… We’re not going to monitor this place 24 hours+7 days/week… Some stuff may slip our notice.

Also, should we really point out that no requests of forbidden material are allowed, like we’re speaking to fucking brats, or even toddlers? Hey, maybe that’s what you are, Shriners? Are you going to try jumping off a cliff, simply because the likes of us don’t tell you that it’s not okay to do so?
Assuming that we’re not really okay with requests of forbidden material is not that big of a leap, logic-wise, so whatever… You’ve had an account registered for a pretty extended amount of time, enough to know. Also, given what I witness in the list of banned users, circumventing a ban by creating another account isn’t allowed, either… Say bye-bye to this one, too.

….
Assuming that we’re not really okay with requests of forbidden material is not that big of a leap, logic-wise, so whatever… You’ve had an account registered for a pretty extended amount of time, enough to know. Also, given what I witness in the list of banned users, circumventing a ban by creating another account isn’t allowed, either… Say bye-bye to this one, too.

Isn’t this going a bit too far as to being personal on the guy? Hey how about a second chance or something? Just asking..

Isn’t this going a bit too far as to being personal on the guy? Hey how about a second chance or something? Just asking..
Nothing personal against the user, others before him got the same treatment.

The error is human.
Don’t be so rude with him please

He made so much for this forum. And you banned him for only one mistake which he admitted and apologized for…

He made so much for this forum. And you banned him for only one mistake which he admitted and apologized for…
If we followed such crappy logic we couldn’t ban anyone, pretty much. Neither the amount, nor the kind of contributions hold any relevance.

Let me start by saying I have absolutely no problem with the forum setting whatever conditions it wants for what can or cannot be shared. And I have no issues with bans for people who share inappropriate music, especially repeat offenders.
However,

Actually the site does mention RE OSTs are prohibited from being posted or even requested on this (Thread 214356) stickied thread.
Read it twice, and I can find no mention of anything about requests, or consequences of requests,

Also, should we really point out that no requests of forbidden material are allowed, like we’re speaking to fucking brats, or even toddlers?
Yes, yes you should. It is a completely reasonable assumption that if you can’t have the links, you can’t request the links. But it is also obvious that if you can’t share the links you can’t share the links privately. That is correctly mentioned on the FAQ. It’s two more words in the description.
Since the forbidden list is subject to change, for me, there is a distinction between asking for something you can’t have, and sending something you can’t provide. Personally, I think a first warning, with reason given, and a ban on the second offense might be better.

I agree that Shriners are their own worst enemy, and that systems seem to exist to be abused, but a tweak might be useful.
JonC

———- Post added at 01:55 PM ———- Previous post was at 01:47 PM ———-

Additional note, I access the Shrine by checking new posts only. Consequently, I don’t believe I ever see updates of the forbidden list. Fortunately, I never make requests.
Anyhoo, it may also be useful to make a separate new post to indicate when the ban list changes, so people like me, who only check new posts, see that the list has been updated.

Personally, I think a first warning, with reason given, and a ban on the second offense might be better.

Totally agree

If I may second that..a reminder sometimes is what we need to keep ourselves in check..

@Leon Scott Kennedy please bro, I didn’t meant to be an ass, unfortunately I let my emotions get in the way. I was just upset and you were just doing your job. All I ask is for one chance…I have no ill intentions nor I have giving any sort problems to anyone here. I just wanna continue sharing what we’re all passionate about, music. If you unban my first account I’ll gladly appreciate it, however if you proceed to ban me again, just wanna say there’s no hard feelings.

@JonC:
I won’t bother doing any of that, why? Because there’s another paragraph which "trumps" all of that and it should be one of the first things we read about:

http://forums.ffshrine.org/register.php

Excerpt from the forum rules:

The owners of Final Fantasy Shrine Forums reserve the right to remove, edit, move or close any content item for any reason.
The moment we sign up (and for as long as we intend to keep using our accounts here) we agree with the fact that owners of the board, as well as those they deem qualified to act on their behalf, can do whatever they want… Without a valid reason. I’m going to stress the last part… Reserve the right to remove […] any content item for any reason.

Unfair? Probably, but forums ain’t democracies and given we have accounts here, we are supposed to have read that bit.

Also, experience showed me that most of the Shriners either don’t bother to read, or conveniently play dumb, there would be no use in making clarifications. Go complain to the admins about me, if you want, but I quite frankly don’t give a damn about the easiness with which I hand out bans, fuck, banned users can effectively come back with another account within minutes from the ban… TC here is just one of the most recent examples.

@Leon Scott Kennedy please bro, I didn’t meant to be an ass, unfortunately I let my emotions get in the way. I was just upset and you were just doing your job. All I ask is for one chance…I have no ill intentions nor I have giving any sort problems to anyone here. I just wanna continue sharing what we’re all passionate about, music. If you unban my first account I’ll gladly appreciate it, however if you proceed to ban me again, just wanna say there’s no hard feelings.
Pro Tip: If you’re going to come back from being banned with a new account don’t tell anybody that you’ve done. Especially don’t do it twice.

@JonC:
I won’t bother doing any of that, why? Because there’s another paragraph which "trumps" all of that and it should be one of the first things we read about:

http://forums.ffshrine.org/register.php
I’ll take your word for it. I can’t actually read this link without signing out.

Excerpt from the forum rules:

The moment we sign up (and for as long as we intend to keep using our accounts here) we agree with the fact that owners of the board, as well as those they deem qualified to act on their behalf, can do whatever they want… Without a valid reason. I’m going to stress the last part… Reserve the right to remove […] any content item for any reason.

Unfair? Probably, but forums ain’t democracies and given we have accounts here, we are supposed to have read that bit.

Also, experience showed me that most of the Shriners either don’t bother to read, or conveniently play dumb, there would be no use in making clarifications. Go complain to the admins about me, if you want, but I quite frankly don’t give a damn about the easiness with which I hand out bans, fuck, banned users can effectively come back with another account within minutes from the ban… TC here is just one of the most recent examples.
I don’t disagree with the Powers That Be having the right to do anything they want for any reasons they want. I’ve been around in organized fandom long enough (Forty years? Where does the time go?) to know that fandom and democracy don’t mix. The most effective, longest lasting, and least headache inducing fan organizations I’ve ever been around were all velvet-gloved dictatorships. And it has been demonstrated repeatedly that members on the Shrine WILL take a mile if given an inch. I look at the tweak as less a challenge to authority or a call for accountability and more as an administrative laxative: it helps to keep the shit from building up.