Does anyone know what has happened to this and when/if it is being released?
Thanks
More likely they didn’t have time to assemble a new album when pieces of Mansell’s work were replaced with Balfe, and Paramount would rather have had no OST release than one without Balfe’s contributions. Maybe we’ll get lucky during awards season; who knows?
As for awards, I would imagine they’d try assembling a FYC campaign for the film at least for visual effects. Maybe they’ll make the score available "for consideration" as well. We’ll see in Fall.
If there’s a lesson here it’s the folly in trying to adapt anime to live action. Anime is a niche genre and there’s a limited audience for it. In other words, don’t try going live action on Akira.
https://twitter.com/Lornebalfe/status/852169116676800512
I think Paramount is going to dump this one, write it off and try to forget it ever happened. The bad news is GiTS’ poor performance dooms future anime adaptations into live action.
https://twitter.com/Lornebalfe/status/852169116676800512
This is just odd. Far lesser films have gotten score releases.
I had no idea about Mr. Balfe’s contributions to the score. What happened there? Every report I read regarding it just spoke about Clint Mansell.
If you think Ms. Johansen clad in a form fitting latex bodysuit looks like a boy, I think you need a refresher in Bio 101.
The problem, IMO, is anime is still largely a niche genre. Most audience, and by that I mean almost every last one, members have no idea about Ghost in the Shell. When it comes to SF audiences tend to be very conservative unless there’s a Star Wars in the title. (I would have added Star Trek, but the last two movies have been meh at the box office.)
Also there was no "hook" in the trailers to reel the audience in: lots of pretty and intriguing images but nothing that said "you gotta see this film."
———- Post added at 11:34 AM ———- Previous post was at 11:33 AM ———-
This is just odd. Far lesser films have gotten score releases.
I had no idea about Mr. Balfe’s contributions to the score. What happened there? Every report I read regarding it just spoke about Clint Mansell.
As I noted previously, this film has the stink of failure, expensive failure. Paramount is distancing themselves from it.
I had no idea about Mr. Balfe’s contributions to the score. What happened there? Every report I read regarding it just spoke about Clint Mansell.
Reshoots and less-than-favorable test audience reactions likely led to a decision by executives that some, not all, of Mansell’s music just did not work for the film. Balfe was brought on at the 11th hour to rescore several sequences.
i have to say it… you are assholes… complaining of a movie… that is not bad. you just wanted SO BAD to be BAD.
oh right… saw 4 times in cinema…. teh more I see, the more it shows its better then the 95 animated…. and fucking love that movie. but now with comparison…. live action is better.
everyone wants it to fail it seems. I want a second movie.
I log out from this insane shitty world of demised humanity, and will go back to a proper world.
score released awaited……
Now, it’s not clear, until an official release surface in the future, if Balfe wrote additional music or additional arrangements to the film or wrote music to replace Mansell’s cues or wrote music to replace Mansell’s cues in the reshoots.
This seems to be a similar case for what happened in Constantine with Brian Tyler and Klaus Badelt.
———- Post added at 09:45 PM ———- Previous post was at 09:36 PM ———-
I’ll say again: I think what’s going on is that Paramount doesn’t want a score album for the film – which Lakeshore has already assembled and, hell, maybe already pressed – which contains large amounts of rejected music. They do not want to pay Lakeshore to assemble a new program and do the same job twice.
…it’s just the same problem the Ghostbusters… thing… had: it can’t stop reminding you there’s another, WAY superior movie with the same name.
Another thing that just gets me is "she looks like a boy", man really? For one i had no idea that they cast Scarlett but after i give that a more thought one movie rised in my mind – Under the skin, Scarlett is amazing there and thats how i was excited about her doing this, many people just see her based on Lucy and Avengers, but dig deeper, that said, this movie done one thing that many doesnt like to do, they took very pretty woman and they didnt make her a sexbomb in this, she is a part machine, she doesnt have too look amazing, she moves like one even when she just walk, she express like one in facial acting, she is cyborg not a model, so yes the femine factor is missing for a very good reason here and thats a great thing about this….
What i thought that is kind of shame was just a few things, yes i would like to see original villain of the original, it changed a context of the story too much, not for a worse, Pitt did good job with Hideo, but still… And second thing is that GITS was always about whole section 9, here they doesnt have much space as Major and thats a shame, but it didnt ruined a movie for me…
Now about the score, does anybody remembers that Clint Mansell would ever did a bad score? Hardly, i rewatched yesterday Stoker what he composed, its brilliant, for godsake he had a job when he was mixing such a classic like a Swan lake in Black swan and he delivered one of the best reamagining of classical composition ever, so what i think about Balfe being added on a last minute is that Paramount expected more Hollywood style of music, i think that even director wasnt exactly on board with that either, if he would be they wouldnt choose a Clint at all, Balfe is modern composer, as a basically apprentice of Zimmer they both does what is expected, which doesnt equel of being good, i didnt enjoyed Zimmer since The pledge, Ring and Broken arrow where he was original, now he is rehashing his performence from Pirates over and over ( Batman is kind of good but still has the same system and symptoms of his new works ), Balfe is not different, his Terminator was generic as hell, but thats the thing, thats what most companys wants today, if its a big movie they rather play safe then experimenting, i think that Clint as always delivered but Paramount didnt want to take a risk… But i dont see that also like a good reason not release the music at all, also that the movie doesnt do well now isnt the issue, there is so much bad movies that didnt delivered yet we have scores, this is by far not a bad movie, not even "generic" as many also says, people just wanted exact copy of original so they didnt try to give it more thought, i enjoyd it very much and i will buy it on BD in a first day, i see it as a part of the series, not as a competition, so there you have it….
Does it exists? Have they ever put a music-only audio track on the Blu-ray before?
The only time I’ve heard about it was rumors for Mad Max: Fury Road and I’m not even sure if that eventually happened or not.
The only time I’ve heard about it was rumors for Mad Max: Fury Road and I’m not even sure if that eventually happened or not.
Isolated score did not happen.
The only time I’ve heard about it was rumors for Mad Max: Fury Road and I’m not even sure if that eventually happened or not.
It’s been quite a while since I’ve watched, but on the DVD of Blade 2 there’s an option to watch the film with just the music and no dialogue/sound FX… which I guess is isolated score (I admit, I’m not familiar with this as a practice either). And that was 2002/2003.
Did you ask him the reason for the score’s delay?
so, youre saying theres a chance? sweet
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tkaJ306bAeQ
Will they just do a film-accurate version by replacing Mansell’s cues with Balfe’s where needed? Or will they drop both composers’ versions of cues?
Sign in done!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tkaJ306bAeQ
Will they just do a film-accurate version by replacing Mansell’s cues with Balfe’s where needed? Or will they drop both composers’ versions of cues?
So, they had the mastered score CD there?
Why haven’t you asked them if you could borrow the CD for 1h 🙂
Why haven’t you asked them if you could borrow the CD for 1h 🙂
They evidently did and I was this close to hahaha (although I don’t think it was the CD they and but just digital files for it)
something out of DVD sales. Have
not seen it. Shame about the score.
We will have to wait and see.
Love Clint’s stuff.
Like someone said previously, far lesser films have had score releases, I’m pretty sure there are others that have had less than stellar box office numbers but the music still came out as scheduled, what makes this one so bad as to completely cancel the score?
So if nothing becomes of the petition then it looks like we will be waiting a year until the Blu Ray release, and someone manages to isolate and work on a full complete score without SFX, which will be no small feat I’d imagine.
And on that note; what’s with all the hate for Lorne Balfe? I’ve read here and else where about people criticizing his involvement, I personally don’t know of much of his work only Terminator: Genisys and I LOVED that score (and movie), and I’m not so up on all the composer news??
The thing about fear: no one makes good decisions based on it. They should release the score but right now, I’m guessing, everyone associated with it just wants it to go away.
The ‘issue’ with Balfe is that he was brought on at the very last minute (we’re talking two weeks before release – and, in regards to the OST albums, after the Mansell-only album has been mastered for release) to re-do parts of the score, including the opening. (I’ve only heard the first 15 mins of the original Mansell score in the special IMAX preview, and the score there was IMHO superior although, in the case of the shelling sequence, further removed from Kawai’s original)
I’d imagine this is why the release got cancelled and Lakeshore dropped it – partly because they prob weren’t up for remastering the album, working out what to do with Mansell’s stuff that wasn’t used in the film, and also what’s sure to be a bunch of complex legal matters in regards to Balfe’s last min involvement. Now with the petition the hope is that either Lakeshore or some other label pick up the unfinished work and get this score out there.
those recording sessions that many get and share here…… no hope on that?
But I find very strange that Balfe didn’t even post a few cues in his website, as he usually does.
No idea, just saw that he had those on his website when checking to see if he’d added any more Star Wars Rebels music and remembered that people made a fuss about there being nothing of the score available so decided to post the links.
Edit: this site (https://medium.com/@gitsost/ghost-in-the-shell-2017-score-credits-7e5d9a5af324) shows that it was Clint Mansell.
Nice . very nice!
😀
I just loved when Aramaki said that !
People that keep perpetuating this BS are the reason this movie did so poorly. Did you even watch the movie? Motoko is in the film, and she is Japanese, and she becomes Mira. I’m a huge fan of the original anime, and I thought the film was fantastic.
End of story for me. Back to the real topic here: Thanks CGCJ for the Kiner links. Still just beyond stupid what’s going on with this score.
yes. my dear. I 10000% agree with you.
Specially….. when no one seems to know that motoko kusanagi is an alias…. stated in the original manga… and it even says "obviously".
I loved the movie, and as a hardcore fan of Masamune, it was very pleased, very damn pleased, enough to see it 5 times in theaters.
So much rage for this movie…. and like you I ask everyone complaining:
"you sure you saw the same movie as I? You sure you really know what you are talking about?
Because for me its NO to both clearly"
I thought "The Leap" was going to be the song of my favorite scene in the movie. The Geisha Dive! I loved that moment so much.
Wow! Thanks for the heads up! These are great! Now if only Lorne would post some clips on his own website too…
the end credits for the film say Mansell.
Def sounds like the original version of the score I heard in the IMAX preview, pre-Balfe.
EDIT: Just listened to the two tracks. Definitely sound different from what I remember in the film. The Leap, I presume, would be the score of the opening action scene where The Major does the building drop. The track sounds almost identical to the score from the film’s end credits which antovolk ripped from the Korean VOD release, which I assumed was a sample ‘suite’ of different pieces of music because it didn’t all sync with one particular scene. However, it seems here that the more dramatic pounding music (3:22 The Leap) was supposed to play when she crashes through the window and takes out the villains before shooting the Geisha-bot; very different to the eerie, atmospheric choir vocals in the finished film. Otherwise, playing it through in my head, the track syncs with the scene – I can here the cues where the Geisha-bot crawls over to her before delivering Kuze’s cryptic message and getting shot in the head.
I have to say, I think Balfe’s work on the score improved it, based on what we’ve heard thus far. I’d love to here Mansell’s original piece for the Shelling Sequence, though, just out of curiosity.
"Shelling"…. I love it …… <3
Nope thats wrong, for one even Mamoru Oshii ( director of 95 original ) said that she is jumping from body to body, she could be japan originaly but that was not a message of that movie, exactly opposite, Kusanagi even says in the Stand alone complex that she jumps as she needs to, when Batou asks her why she doesnt use a male body, she reply that she chooses this for flexibility as the woman are known for, after some time Batou even figure that she wants her hands to be small enough to wear specific watches, why? Watch it… Both movies and series never ever stated clearly what exact origin is she, they even dont care for what race she is captured, Oshii said that he actually did her more european mixed with asian look, so no, its not whitewashing, in the end the USA version actually break this of by telling us that she was originaly japanese girl, so i dont see any problem here…
Now second thing, if you ever saw Under the skin, you would know why they picked Scarlett, yes she is famous right now too, but look at other movies she was in, there is more then a just a talent in here, this hatred towards casting is just pointless if you ask me, because when even japanese people are ok with it then its really weird when rest of the world goes mad about it….
although the bluray has a great cover art, its is still super expensive in my country.
I just hope…. someone might get the soundtrack job done.
although the bluray has a great cover art, its is still super expensive in my country.
I just hope…. someone might get the soundtrack job done.
Well my friend, we share the somewhat the same kind of problems, im from Czech republic and man our distribution plain and simply suck ass, i found myself wondering why they even try when it comes with dvd releases anymore, quality is bad, we are getting old movies late ( we just got for a first time ever Childs play 2 and 3 ) with basic quality and no bonus material anywhere, not a mention about tv shows, they actually released two seasons of The walking dead and after just telling us, well we dont release the rest of it, and thats a one of the most popular tv show these days… So we dont have any kind of secluded "music only track" on BD too, we have to be happy if we do get the movie itself, as long user of playstation which does have BD player this kind of treatment is just sad, so im about to start ignoring our shops and let most of the things send out online….
That said i dont have much hopes for getting a BD with music track option too, and for worse i can order only region 2 version ( kill region locks already its bullshit! ) so i hope that UK version will be good, but i can only hope that US version will have that option because official soundtrack release seems to not being happenning for time being….
Thanks CGCJ! 😀
That said i dont have much hopes for getting a BD with music track option too, and for worse i can order only region 2 version ( kill region locks already its bullshit! ) so i hope that UK version will be good, but i can only hope that US version will have that option because official soundtrack release seems to not being happenning for time being….
yeah. we both live in europe. Portugal Sucks in this kind of movie distribution. But not in the past… in the past it were original dvds adding only the subtitles and everything else was kept, like extras and stuff. I most of teh times I liek to see my movies with english subs. My transformers movie of 2007 dvd is like that. tons of subs or dubs, and I just chose what I want.
Hansel and Grettel with hunters and Super8, i got those dvds in recent promotion…. and they are official releases IN my country. only english audio, and forced subs. yeah. forced subs because you can deactivate them. Kind like fansubs with hardcoded subs. very stupid!!! I have problems with the translations of my country. "Ghost In The Shell" was raw translated in my language as "Haunted City". I AM NOT KIDDING!!! that is the exact raw translation from my language to English. Here they translated 3×3 eyes (another anime) to "Revolt of the humans".
Hansel and Grettel with hunters and Super8, i got those dvds in recent promotion…. and they are official releases IN my country. only english audio, and forced subs. yeah. forced subs because you can deactivate them. Kind like fansubs with hardcoded subs. very stupid!!! I have problems with the translations of my country. "Ghost In The Shell" was raw translated in my language as "Haunted City". I AM NOT KIDDING!!! that is the exact raw translation from my language to English. Here they translated 3×3 eyes (another anime) to "Revolt of the humans".
Oh yeah i know what you mean, i dont watch movies with our voice over dub like more then 15 years because the translation just sucks and also i like full actor effort, acting is in the voice too…
And oh boy we can really make funny titles too for example…
The gift – Almost perfect crime
The messangers – The house on sunflower field ( like its seriously dumb when you name a horror based on location of house )
Ginger snaps – My sister werewolf
Cruel intentions – Very dangerous friends
Also we did many times adding things to amplify, Speed – Dangerous speed, and stuff like that, most sad fact is that if you are waiting for a release in a theater you cant be even sure if its the same movie in program, its funny….
And what about the Mansell’s score? Didn’t it surface until now?