Which was better, Rogue Galaxy or Odin Sphere?

These are tied for the 5th best rpg release in the Spring season by me, based on their popularity and reviews. Here’s a tentative order…

1. World of Warcraft: The Burning Crusade(PC)
2. The Elder Scrolls IV: The Shivering Isles(PC, Xbox 360)
3. Super Paper Mario(Wii)
4. The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion(w/ Knights of the Nine)(PS 3)
5th or 6th. Rogue Galaxy
5th or 6th. Odin Sphere

I have Rogue Galaxy and am 13 hours into it. I have never played Odin Sphere. Both are action rpg’s released this spring for Playstation 2 with roughly the same level of popularity, so I thought a poll would be a good thing to make.

Since I haven’t played Odin Sphere I may not choose one, I’ll vote for I don’t know. What is your choice and comments? 🙂

Never played Rogue Galaxy so I go for Odin Sphere.

odin sphere

WoW Is For Ppl Who Don’t Have Lives And Spend Over $100 Bucks (Plus Paying Every Month To Keep There Acc Active) For Red Bulls Just To Stay Up All Night And Say "Weee I Got A Lvl Up" Or The Obvious "Oh My Gosh New Armor For My Dude". To Put It In Terms It Controls Your Life In A Scary Way. Anyways Rogue Galaxy Its Fun Plus More Action In Ways How You Play It.

If you haven’t played one of the two games, IDX Rider, and others, please vote for "I don’t know".

The website for Odin Sphere has great music! 🙂

The story in Rogue Galaxy is ok, how good is the story in Odin Sphere? Ultimately a rpg game seems to be remembered for a great story and characters and music I believe. Final Fantasy VI dominates those categories! 🙂

If you haven’t played one of the two games, IDX Rider, and others, please vote for "I don’t know".
Who cares. It’s nothing but a poll that means basically nothing.

I never played Rogue Galaxy…I’ve played Odin Sphere. I won’t vote for Odin Sphere. I liked it for a while, but it’s definitely not something I’d recommend people to buy IMO.

Odin Sphere definitely…
Rogue Galaxy has many cool aspects but i got bored after a while…
truth is 3d doesn’t always mean better game…

Rogue Galaxy’s a much deeper game.

I wish there were more votes on this topic but we still had some.

Which is more successful? Also, how do these two titles compare to the fall rpg’s released so far which are in a similar league to it: Persona 3, Blue Dragon, and Eternal Sonata? I didn’t list The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass because I think it’s generally considered to be a better game. 😀

I rented Persona 3 for 3 hours and thought it was good. I rented Blue Dragon and played like an hour and a half but didn’t like it. Eternal Sonata is great and I’m 16 hours into the game! I want to rent Zelda: PH later this year when I have a DS for FF XII: RW.

I’ve heard a lot better things about Rogue Galaxy, and nothing particularly special about Odin Sphere. Despite Odin Sphere appealing to me at a "book’s cover" basis.

Man your floodin this place with polls. I went with Rogue Galaxy.

I still need to play Odin Sphere.

For those that liked Rogue Galaxy and Odin Sphere? Their main counterparts for the Fall this year may be: Persona 3, Blue Dragon, and Eternal Sonata. What do you think of those ones? 😀

I still need to play Odin Sphere.

For those that liked Rogue Galaxy and Odin Sphere? Their main counterparts for the Fall this year may be: Persona 3, Blue Dragon, and Eternal Sonata. What do you think of those ones? 🙂

EDIT:
How do I delete this post? Where’s the delete button on the Editing page?

WoW Is For Ppl Who Don’t Have Lives And Spend Over $100 Bucks (Plus Paying Every Month To Keep There Acc Active) For Red Bulls Just To Stay Up All Night And Say "Weee I Got A Lvl Up" Or The Obvious "Oh My Gosh New Armor For My Dude". To Put It In Terms It Controls Your Life In A Scary Way. Anyways Rogue Galaxy Its Fun Plus More Action In Ways How You Play It.

Stop Printing Everything Like Its The Start Of A Sentence.

As for which is best, I don’t know. Never played OS, but I have RG, and its pretty nice. I’m at the last point until you hafta fight through 20 bosses to beat the game, but I just can’t do it. TWENTY-FREAKIN’-BOSSES!!!! Why? Why the heck do you HAVE to fight 20? There should be a secret level or bonus dungeon afterwards.

I still need to play Odin Sphere.

For those that liked Rogue Galaxy and Odin Sphere? Their main counterparts for the Fall this year may be: Persona 3, Blue Dragon, and Eternal Sonata. What do you think of those ones? 😀

Persona 3 kicks ass,it might be even better than the other 2…as for the other 2 haven’t played em but they’ll be on me next list probably 😀

Kalmah, what’s the origin of your username? Also, why are their 20 straight bosses?

Persona 3 is loved by everybody! I never heard any bad comment about the game. I thought the 3 hours I played were good but I don’t need to buy it. I recommend the game though. Rent Blue Dragon and Eternal Sonata!

Blue Dragon I rented and I didn’t like it much. Eternal Sonata I’m beating within a few days. I’m currently renting it but I’m buying my official copy in a half hour! 🙂

EDIT:
Let’s start a new poll! What game is better: Persona 3, Blue Dragon, or Eternal Sonata?!

My vote is for Eternal Sonata, what’s your vote for?

The origin of my user name is from the all mighty melodic death metal group, KALMAH!! [www.kalmah.com]

I dunno why there are 20 bosses, but GameFAQS said there are 20 bosses.

As for the new poll, never played any o’ them.

Lets have a picnic! Kalmah fuckin rules.

Yes I do fucking rule. As for a pic-nic… well… Only if you’re a hot big breasted female, over 18. HA!

Eternal Sonata is going great for me. I have only the final boss left in the game and the bonus dungeon left to do.

The sidequests in this game(not including the New Game+ "Encore" 2nd playthrough stuff) are:
Collecting all score pieces(I got all but one or two in the first playthrough)
Doing the trading(I didn’t do this, wasn’t paying attention when I should have started it, in the end it wasn’t necessary or too important)
Bonus Dungeon "Mysterious Unison"(I’m doing this tonight, I’ve saved right outside the entrance)

I’m currently 31 hours into the game I believe. I’m getting pretty excited! 🙂

I wish I had more time/money to play the top rpg’s and that I had beaten some of the top older rpg’s already so I could focus on the new ones. If that was the situation I’d beat these rpg’s this fall…

Jeanne D’Arc(assuming I like it)
Eternal Sonata
Final Fantasy Tactics: The War of the Lions(CRITICAL!)
Front Mission
Final Fantasy XI: Wings of the Goddess(CRITICAL!)
Final Fantasy XII: Revenant Wings(CRITICAL!)
…after beating these ones, I’d beat a couple games I delayed beating…
The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass
Mass Effect

The little guy in the top hat looks cool. I wish I had a top hat, or that they’d come back in style.

Yes I do fucking rule. As for a pic-nic… well… Only if you’re a hot big breasted female, over 18. HA!

I was talking about the band ruling dude haha. Oh and the picnic was really cheery and happy and shit like the guy runnin this thread:
"Let’s start a new poll! What game is better: Persona 3, Blue Dragon, or Eternal Sonata?!"

LoL

The little guy in the top hat looks cool. I wish I had a top hat, or that they’d come back in style.

You mean Frederic Chopin from Eternal Sonata? Yea it’s great! My Uncle wore one for his wedding, and had a cane also. 😀

Top Hat

Frederic Chopin from Eternal Sonata