Don't know if a thread about this has been done before, but which old rpgs would you like to see remade and if so what changes would like to see made. Just be imaginative and list 3 or more games.

My choice of rpgs for a remake of the top my head would be:
Lufia 1&2:New features of course would have to include updated 3D graphics.

Alundra: Again updated 3D graphics and IMO I think voiceovers would really make the game more enjoyable as the plot was fairly good.

Golden Sun: I always imagined this game would've looked good on Gamecube with a mix of 2D and 3D graphics much like the gba version but more detailed.

Shin Megami Tensei 1&2: I hope Atlus decides to do this but if they did and made it similiar to Nocturne it would great.

Crystalis?

I think a remake of FF8 would be cool. Like graphics and voices and more side-quests. And a fix on the junction system or something so the game would be more of a challenge.

Can't really think of any other RPGs that I would like to be remade. I was about to say Tomb Raider II but that's not an RPG hehe.

Xenogears for the DS!

How about a remake of the very first Phantasy Star?

Remake of these games with nice graphics and audio, as well improved gameplay and ported in a console like PS2 or PSP:

Phantasy Star 3
Phantasy Star 4
Final Fantasy Legend III
Final Fantasy 7
Final Fantasy 8
7th Saga
Arcana
Secret of the Stars
Quest 64

Sorry had to post this for the following...

No... NOT 7th Saga. I need a cheat for that game. >.> REALLY hard RPG.

---

I actually agree with the Estopolis (aka Lufia)... too bad the third one sucked so badly.

Phantasy Star 1 had a remake for the J PS2 (and so did 2).

I would like to add:
- Secret of Mana 2 & 3

I would have to agree with Quest 64. Magi-Nation also deserves a third chance as well as Radia Senki. Above all else though...LIVE-A-LIVE

There is pretty much no game save Xenogears I'd like to see remade and that is because of my unreasonably biased adoration for that game.

The rest are good games which they think we don't want/couldn't afford to port:

Bahamut Lagoon

Samurai Showdown RPG

and for god's sake, RPG or not give us a damn Evangelion game finally.

I seriously doubt Quest 64 could be remade into something good.

Ogre Battle: March of the Black Queen

Dragon Quest/warrior 1

Shining force 1

Bahamut Lagoon
Vagrant Story

Does an RPG request count if it's already been done?

Because Ys: The Oath in Felghana is one of my favorite Action RPGs on the PC...I just wish it would get an official US release, complete with voiceovers ala Ark of Napishtim.

It would make a great fit on the new gen consoles as well. Or, if the graphics are dumbed down a bit, would make an outstanding final-release for the Playstation 2 (if they haven't stopped making games for it already.)

Seiken Densetsu 3 for the wii or DS. With Orchestrated music/ Arranged

Sorry had to post this for the following...

No... NOT 7th Saga. I need a cheat for that game. >.> REALLY hard RPG.

---


It was pretty hard that i remember & i got lost on several occasions trying to find the next quest and characters.

Hmmmm.....Perhaps Terranigma. A lesser known game, but awesome in it's own right. It would be amazing on the 360.

While I'm sure it would never happen, I'd would be interesting to see someone try turning Darklands' predominantly text-based gameworld into something a little more graphical. Maybe not on the same scale (hand crafting 100+ locations would be kind of crazy) but with the same game rules and setting.

Remakes of the following would be nice:

Suikoden
Vandal Hearts
Mystaria: Realms of Lore

i hated Vandal Hearts.

I'd like to see every FF remade for ps3. That would be awesome. Also, Chrono Cross and Legend of the Dragoon would be great!

i hated Vandal Hearts.

:finger:

Obey the will of the Mighty Megatron!


I'd like to see every FF remade for ps3. That would be awesome. Also, Chrono Cross and Legend of the Dragoon would be great!

Chrono Cross and Legend of Dragoon remade? Maybe Chrono Cross, but Legend of Dragoon Idk... I've finished LoD years ago... but unlike other RPG's on the PSX, I've never felt the urge to replay it again. Still, to each their own.

seriously man, i hated V Hearts. Remake Crystalis, like whosit said up there.

Vandal Hearts was superior than it's sequel imo. Good title, still w/e

Star Ocean 3 for XBox360. I miss playing SO3.

If they remake things, they can edit certain details and I did enjoy LoD except for small parts. I've never gotten to play the Final Fantasies before VII, so I'd like to with updated visuals and whatnot. Not sure about which ones are most liked or not in that bunch :/

If they remake things, they can edit certain details and I did enjoy LoD except for small parts. I've never gotten to play the Final Fantasies before VII, so I'd like to with updated visuals and whatnot. Not sure about which ones are most liked or not in that bunch :/

I prefer the original graphics from the SNES and NES myself, but then I grew up with them on those consoles so I guess I can enjoy them more. I'd recommend I, IV and VI though.

While I'm not sure I would enjoy a straight up remake, I did immensely enjoy Ogre Battle 64, and would love for a developer to take a look at the gameplay and story there and keep the ball rolling in terms of adding interesting gameplay elements and even more complex army control. For those unfamiliar with it, Ogre Battle 64 had characters and classes reminiscent of a Final Fantasy game, but you were able to control entire armies to move around a strategic battlefield to capture territory and cities. Unless I'm mistaken, after Ogre Battle 64 there haven't been any recent Ogre Battle games.

So that is what I would want to see more of, whether remade or restarted.

Can't afford them at this point but I do want to get them someday. I have many games I want to play that are older and I didn't get a chance to, the biggest being Chrono Trigger and Xenogears. I'll give them all a chance, afterall, I doubt they could disappoint me more than FFXII did.

I wish "they" would re-make the idea of an original game. While porting older games to newer systems for nostalgia's sake is all well and good, I want to play something new. If I really had my wish, there'd be some originality, a bit of charm, and perhaps the occasional clever idea involved.

I wish "they" would re-make the idea of an original game. While porting older games to newer systems for nostalgia's sake is all well and good, I want to play something new. If I really had my wish, there'd be some originality, a bit of charm, and perhaps the occasional clever idea involved.

Seconded.

If they remake things, they can edit certain details and I did enjoy LoD except for small parts. I've never gotten to play the Final Fantasies before VII, so I'd like to with updated visuals and whatnot. Not sure about which ones are most liked or not in that bunch :/

Ohh, give these games a try:

Final Fantasy I & II; Dawn of Souls
Final Fantasy III DS
Final Fantasy IV Advance / DS
Final Fantasy V Advance
Final Fantasy VI Advance
(and maybe) Chrono Trigger DS

^^ There you go, those are all the classics in an updated, but still original, form, which I guarantee you'll love! I can't tell you which ones are "better", but I can tell you they're all equally awesome! I can't recommend 'em enough!

The majority of the earlier Final Fantasy games were remade for the PlayStation and should still be available. Only Final Fantasy III wasn't remade for the PlayStation.

Star Ocean 3 for XBox360. I miss playing SO3.

Yeah, because remaking a last gen game is always a great idea...

The majority of the earlier Final Fantasy games were remade for the PlayStation and should still be available. Only Final Fantasy III wasn't remade for the PlayStation.

I keep forgetting about the PSX versions; yes, those are definitely worth a shot too. Dawn of Souls is a very faithful port of FFOrigins, with the exception of the CG intros being omitted. But FFIII is worth buying a DS for all in itself.

I can't afford them at the time being but when I can I definately wanna get them. And I meant PS3 remade. I do wanna try the updated versions and I knew they were out there, but I'd prefer all grandly remade for new-gen. That'd be awesome :D

I can't afford them at the time being but when I can I definately wanna get them. And I meant PS3 remade. I do wanna try the updated versions and I knew they were out there, but I'd prefer all grandly remade for new-gen. That'd be awesome :D

Just out of curiosity, is the reason you'd like to see them 'remade for new-gen' for 'better' graphics?

Graphics, voice acting added in, edits in certain storyline areas where it was a bit foggy, to all be on one console so I don't have to buy a bunch of consoles to play them, etc......many reasons, but yes, updated graphics would be nice too. I am an artist so that would be a plus to me. But once again, not the *only* reason.

(http://img156.imageshack.us/i/facepalm2u.jpg/)

Call me a traditionalist, old fashioned etc... I prefer the original format, and whenever someone says they want 'better graphics etc', I die a little on the inside...

I have to agree with Death's Head. If someone remakes a game, not making any effort to refine the gameplay or introduce something new seems lazy.

That and I always hate people who shy away from trying older awesome games simply because their graphics aren't Crysis-esque or better. I have a friend like that, so they do exist.

I already said I wanted to play the older ones AND I already said I wanted story elements refined.......and I'd like the graphics to be updated. Besides, it's not like the old games cease to exist if they get remade. They'll always be there to play remake or no remake, so unless they totally screw up the remake there's really little to no reason to complain.

I'd say that with the earliest games from the NES asking for an overhaul with revamped story and voices is almost like saying you don't want to play them at all, but this is a thread for wishful thinking so I guess it doesn't matter.

I'd like to see a PS3 update of Final Fantasy Legend. Detailed 3D graphics, full voice, and cinemas for all of the unforgettable moments like when you beat 'King Sword' at 'Castle Sword' to get the 'King Sword'. And who can forget the drama at 'Castle Shield'... make it happen SE.

Nothin wrong with a visual update as long as it isn't the sole reason for a remake. cos while looks aren't everything, they definitely matter.

I already said I wanted to play the older ones AND I already said I wanted story elements refined.......and I'd like the graphics to be updated. Besides, it's not like the old games cease to exist if they get remade. They'll always be there to play remake or no remake, so unless they totally screw up the remake there's really little to no reason to complain.

I'm going to hazard the guess, that the first Final Fantasy game you played was on the PS2, right? Most of the people clambering about the earlier FF's to be remade with better graphics, story elements made better etc are the ones who can't be bothered playing the earlier versions on their respective consoles, due to a preconceived notion that it won't be any good. You have your own choice on the matter and I respect that, however I do find myself disagreeing with your post. Oh well, can't please everybody.


Nothin wrong with a visual update as long as it isn't the sole reason for a remake. cos while looks aren't everything, they definitely matter.

I don't think that's the case myself. I prefer the original graphics myself as they offer the player the chance to use their imagination to decide upon what the character would look like, sound like etc. Graphics aren't essential imo to make a game great. Story, Characters, and all the rest are more important, graphics are just the icing on the cake.

I already said I wanted to play the older ones AND I already said I wanted story elements refined.......and I'd like the graphics to be updated. Besides, it's not like the old games cease to exist if they get remade. They'll always be there to play remake or no remake, so unless they totally screw up the remake there's really little to no reason to complain.

You can play all the old ones for free. Gogo.

I'm going to hazard the guess, that the first Final Fantasy game you played was on the PS2, right? Most of the people clambering about the earlier FF's to be remade with better graphics, story elements made better etc are the ones who can't be bothered playing the earlier versions on their respective consoles, due to a preconceived notion that it won't be any good. You have your own choice on the matter and I respect that, however I do find myself disagreeing with your post. Oh well, can't please everybody.
I don't think that's the case myself. I prefer the original graphics myself as they offer the player the chance to use their imagination to decide upon what the character would look like, sound like etc. Graphics aren't essential imo to make a game great. Story, Characters, and all the rest are more important, graphics are just the icing on the cake.

WRONG...I believe I've already said, even on this thread that I played VII-XII...my first being VIII then VII back when I was like 15. Also, I think you're not even reading my whole posts & are just picking out what you want it to say, cause I've had to say the same thing like 3 times now & you just keep repeating that I only want graphics to be remade which is not what I said. It is part of what I want remade & graphics are a part of games. If they made remakes, yes I'd like improved graphics. It'd be awesome to see Squall on PS3! But I do believe in every single post I've written on this thread I have stated & restressed that that's not the ONLY reason. I also think I made a good enough point by saying that if you prefer the older ones, it's not like a remake is gonna take those out of existence. You can play the older ones only & I'd play both the older ones & the remakes. Fair enough? It's the games before VII I haven't gotten to play yet & I'd prefer not to have to go hunting them & whatever console they're on so yeah, all being on PS3 would be awesome. This is all fantasy remake anyway, so not like it matters.

I don't think that's the case myself. I prefer the original graphics myself as they offer the player the chance to use their imagination to decide upon what the character would look like, sound like etc. Graphics aren't essential imo to make a game great. Story, Characters, and all the rest are more important, graphics are just the icing on the cake.

i don't think anyone disagrees with that. but good graphics don't ruin a good game. maybe your own personal nostalgia of it

My all time greatest RPG remake wish would be Earthbound. Leave the graphics cartoony, go with a cell shaded styling that emulates the sprites well enough, don't change the text or the story at all, but maybe add a challenge area..... it'd be awesome.

I already said I wanted to play the older ones AND I already said I wanted story elements refined.......and I'd like the graphics to be updated. Besides, it's not like the old games cease to exist if they get remade. They'll always be there to play remake or no remake, so unless they totally screw up the remake there's really little to no reason to complain.
To the whole debacle.
A fine example - Lunar SSS PSP. Though I'm not sure if they're refining the story (too lazy to reread stuff about it). Graphics overhauled at least.


Nothin wrong with a visual update as long as it isn't the sole reason for a remake. cos while looks aren't everything, they definitely matter.
So true...
FF1&2 PSP. They increased the encounters dramatically, and the JP version already had an english translation as an option. It also kind of looks like something you can make with RPGMaker XP/VX. I mean, I liked FF1 and all, but it has almost no story. Maybe some stuff, like Pre-Garland kidnaps princess, an explanation of the fiends and crystals, you know, typical expanding stuff.. Though the game pulls a Sonic '06. And if we're talking about nostalgia here, how about the buff white mage?

Ontopic - I'd love a remake of... shining force 3, cause I never got the chance to play it. Sure, there's emulation, but I'm lazy. (Actually, I couldn't get the blasted thing to work.) Besides, they had corny polygon/battle scenes.

WRONG...I believe I've already said, even on this thread that I played VII-XII...my first being VIII then VII back when I was like 15. Also, I think you're not even reading my whole posts & are just picking out what you want it to say, cause I've had to say the same thing like 3 times now & you just keep repeating that I only want graphics to be remade which is not what I said. It is part of what I want remade & graphics are a part of games. If they made remakes, yes I'd like improved graphics. It'd be awesome to see Squall on PS3! But I do believe in every single post I've written on this thread I have stated & restressed that that's not the ONLY reason. I also think I made a good enough point by saying that if you prefer the older ones, it's not like a remake is gonna take those out of existence. You can play the older ones only & I'd play both the older ones & the remakes. Fair enough? It's the games before VII I haven't gotten to play yet & I'd prefer not to have to go hunting them & whatever console they're on so yeah, all being on PS3 would be awesome. This is all fantasy remake anyway, so not like it matters.

And as I stated in a earlier thread, the earlier FF games have been ported to the PlayStation and are readily available at a good price in most gaming stores.

I still do stand by my point:

Most of the people clambering about the earlier FF's to be remade with better graphics, story elements made better etc are the ones who can't be bothered playing the earlier versions on their respective consoles, due to a preconceived notion that it won't be any good.

The majority of people I have spoken to personally, at game stores, conventions etc have all raved about how great the FF games are, yet when asked about the earlier games (On the SNES and NES) they frown and say they don't like them due to bad graphics, story etc.

But...I'd already said I still wanted to play the older ones. Never said I wouldn't want to play them due to graphics. I said if in a dream world I could get remakes, they'd be all the FFs on PS3 so I could have them all together on one console and I'd like edited storyline(like some kind of convo with Squall and Laguna about him being his father etc), added features, voice acting, graphic update, etc. That's what I said. Maybe *some* people would say that about only wanting graphics, but I never said that. Even if there were these magical dream remakes for PS3, if I could ever get enough money together to get the older ones, I still would.....also, it'd take me forever to get the remakes due to that same reason, but at least they'd be in one place and my bro has a PS3 so I wouldn't have to buy one.

And as I stated in a earlier thread, the earlier FF games have been ported to the PlayStation and are readily available at a good price in most gaming stores.

Not to mention the GBA, DS and PSP as well, but your point still stands. :D

Getting back on topic, I admit I'd love to see a remake of the original Shadowrun (the Aussie-made SNES version, not that recent crap 360 tie-in game of the same name). Fantastic game that is one of my all time favourites.

Naturally, the important thing would be to preserve the classic gameplay and story. But seeing a year 2050 techno-fantasy Seattle rendered in next gen graphics would just be the tasty icing on an already delicious cake. ;)

Not to mention the GBA, DS and PSP as well, but your point still stands. :D

Getting back on topic, I admit I'd love to see a remake of the original Shadowrun (the Aussie-made SNES version, not that recent crap 360 tie-in game of the same name). Fantastic game that is one of my all time favourites.

Naturally, the important thing would be to preserve the classic gameplay and story. But seeing a year 2050 techno-fantasy Seattle rendered in next gen graphics would just be the tasty icing on an already delicious cake. ;)

One, I'd really like to see a remake of the recent Xbox game, I didn't think it was so bad, it was just not what it should have been. I didn't reallise I was getting an arena only game... Thought it'd actually be tied into the real shadow run.

Also, the Snes shadowrun is godly. a remake of that would be awesome.

Also, Granstream saga... best combat system ever...

For the PC all of the old SSI (Strategic Simulations Incorporated) rpgs, remade for a newer generation. Games like Champions of Kyrnn, Treasures of the Savage Frontier, Death Knights of Kyrnn, Dark Queen of Krynn, Pool of Radiance and others. I remember playing these back on my old 486 SX33 PC back in the early '90's. Great games...

Also, Sierra's, Quest for Glory series remade would be good as well. I found my old copy of Quest for Glory IV: Shadows of Darkness and I'm wishing it'd run on this damn laptop of mine... but Windows Crapsta won't allow it.

Final Fantasy I & II for DS.

Hoping about FFI will be different from the first FFI. This time, one warrior of light appear nearby Cornelia just like in the ending in Dissidia where he started to journey and have a same story but one warrior might want to meet the other characters who hold the other 3 crystals.

In FFII, same plot in both Origins and PSP version. But, this time, the same face of Firion, Maria, Guy & Leon in CG opening. Can be mini character just like in FFIII.

I agree with Anthony. I & II could stand the same treatment III and IV got. They've both seen port after port after port with little to no changes in between, and so far Dawn of Souls has (in my opinion) been the best iteration yet. After the completely unnecessary (well, I suppose necessary to make a few extra bucks) PSP ports, which basically were no different than what we've already seen, I'd either say the two games have seen enough ports, or that they need a 3-d upgrade to finally say, 'Final Fantasy I & II have been done enough, and this is it'.

Planescape: Torment. I don't really care if it's remade, it's the best game ever the way it is. Just fucking re-assemble Black Isle and make a sequel.

Frankenstein: Through The Eyes of The Monster could stand a remake.