Hi all.

I've been reading a lot of posts around this forum, and I keep hearing people state repeatedly that FFVII's plot holes are a reason the game is bad. I don't even want to get into the "is FFVII terrible or not" discussion, but I would like to hear what these purported plot holes are. I've played the game twice, although not recently, and cannot recall a single one.

Could someone please fill me in on this? Thank you.

And from the lack of responses, I rest my case that FFVII has no plot holes, and thus it cannot be justifiably used by people as a reason for disliking or hating the game.

But you are welcome to your other reasons. Your opinions are your own.

ROFL.

1.) Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence
2.) In regards to #1 no one has been here to reply, seeing as the subforums here are particularly slow.

Patience. They will come.

You speak truth. I'm just impatient for a debate, what can I say? =)

can't really think of any plot holes but Bugenhagen contradicts himself by saying Nanaki is the last of his species but then later tells him that he may find a mate adventuring with cloud

Well, I don't think that is a plot hole because it seems like Nanaki and his species is capable of breeding with species other than itself. After all, Hojo puts him and Aeris in a prison cell together with the intention of breeding him with the Cetra. And, while Hojo has questionable mental faculties, that only appears to affect his personality and not his intellect. So, by Bugenhagen saying Red might find a mate adventuring with Cloud, that is possible given his ability to breed with other species. Not a particularly nice image, but one possible given the story!

true gross but true,

i couldn't think of any plot holes so i tried google and found this

Though the WEAPONs awaken to combat Sephiroth and Meteor, once his barrier is destroyed none of the remaining Weapons attack him.

Well, I don't think that is a plot hole because it seems like Nanaki and his species is capable of breeding with species other than itself. After all, Hojo puts him and Aeris in a prison cell together with the intention of breeding him with the Cetra. And, while Hojo has questionable mental faculties, that only appears to affect his personality and not his intellect. So, by Bugenhagen saying Red might find a mate adventuring with Cloud, that is possible given his ability to breed with other species. Not a particularly nice image, but one possible given the story!

Disagree here. You are ASSUMING that he can reproduce with other species, it is NEVER explained (specially in the end) how he did reproduce.

You're reading way too much into it.

chrono357 - But what weapons are left at that point? My memory of the game is hazy, but it seems like all of them are destroyed at this point. I do not count Emerald and Ruby weapon, because they were added in the American/International version of the game in an effort to make some harder extra content available for more hardcore gamers. But, even if there were still one or two weapons around at the time of the barrier's destruction, would they really try to attack Sephiroth at the point? How do they differentiate between threats? Wasn't the Sister Ray (the giant cannon that was fired to take out Diamond Weapon and the barrier) fired by taking in an enormous amount of Mako energy (planet lifeblood)?

I mention that last one because the Weapons don't seem all too intelligent regarding what they regard as threats, and would attack the location of the Sister Ray with full force instead of Sephiroth's location given the immense draw on the planet's lifeblood caused by the Sister Ray. By comparison, we aren't really sure what Sephiroth is doing that would actually draw the Weapons to him and mark him as a threat. He wants to be at the location where Meteor hits so he can draw the surge of defensive lifestream into his body and 'become a god', but how would the planet even know this? I don't think he would be considered a threat by the planet until this moment, causing any remaining Weapons to charge the Sister Ray until this time. And we wouldn't know, because our the characters under our control at in the North Cave at this point.

Therefore, I don't think that is a plot hole, merely leaving us to draw our own conclusions logically from the information given. A plot hole would be something that is completely illogical and has no explanation other than developer laziness/accident.

Neo Xzhan - Well, I thought that the explanation in the game was enough... I mean, do you really want to hear an explanation about how he can reproduce with other species? I sure don't. They drop hints like the ones mentioned earlier, but they don't want to get into some horrifying conversation from Bugenhagen to Nanaki about how a man wolf-creature and woman make a baby. And I am happy with that!

But what weapons are left at that point? My memory of the game is hazy, but it seems like all of them are destroyed at this point.

Just the ultimate weapon if you dont attack and kill it before the barrier is gone


but they don't want to get into some horrifying conversation from Bugenhagen to Nanaki about how a man wolf-creature and woman make a baby. And I am happy with that!.

but im not ;)

I shudder to think of some fan fiction out there that undoubtedly depicts Nanaki getting it on with a human. Ugh...

Final Fantasy 7 is not that bad. It isn't wonderful either.

Here is some issues of concern regarding plot "holes". I prefer to call them places where it just doesn't make sense.

1) How did Aeries' mother escape a high security facility that subdued Cloud's beastly crew?

2) Why was Aeries never captured during her time in sector 5? I assume one of the reasons is that she was dating Zack, who protected her. What about afterwards, while he was AFK for 4 years in a Mako Tank.

3) On that note, why was Zack in the Mako tank for 4 years in the first place? Mako did not affect him and he decided to break out during feeding time 4 years after he was captured. Huh? Why not earlier? He was fucking SOLDIER. Anyway.

4) How did Cloud survive a straight up Masamune stab? Let alone have the strength to throw Sephiroth into the Lifestream? If I recall, Zack got owned. And Cloud is like straight noob compared to Zack.

5) The entire thing about Chaos is like random backstory that was never expanded upon until later Final fantasy spinoffs. You shouldnt need spinoffs to explain events in the game.


Again, it isn't as much plot holes, as some shit just made no sense. Furthermore, you're wrong.

WEAPONS weren't awakened to kill Sephy. They were awakened to kill all of life and return as many souls to the lifestream as possible. This would give the lifestream the strength it needed to stop Sephiroth. Why did the planet not attack sephiroth directly with the weapons? EVEN THOUGH it had already known that Jenova was a threat and the planet was crying blah fucking blah. That would be a very obvious plot hole. The weapons are created by the planet for a purpose btw. It just doesn't make sense why it wouldn't attack sephy.

And also, Red XIII can reproduce with humans.

Hehe, you got me there. Most of those do not make much sense, although I'll still attempt to address them as best I can. But you are right; FFVII is certainly not perfect, but to a certain extent I don't think I personally would like it as much if it lacked certain ambiguous parts of the story. Oftentimes it is the least clear-cut games/books/movies that stick with you in the end and make you think.

1. Aeris' mother escape - There is no explanation for this. We receive no evidence that Ancients/Cetra have combat powers that would allow them to escape a high security facility, and even if they did, such a facility owned by Shinra would undoubtedly have information on these powers and how to overwhelm them. Other than heightened magical affinity, Aeris never exhibits much extraordinary powers, and using her as an example of all Cetra would indicate that there is absolutely no reason Ifalna should have been able to escape. And Shinra would certainly not discard her or let her walk away. Hence, this must be a plot hole.

2. Why was Aeris never captured - In the game it seems like there has been a short history of The Turks and Shinra trying to persuade and co-opt Aeris into joining them. Why they wanted her to join them willingly seems unclear though, and it seems rather convenient that the moment they choose to take her by force, Cloud happens to be there. However, we don't know how long Shinra has known of her being of Cetra blood, and thus it is possible that they haven't actually been looking for her for very long, which would excuse the fact that they didn't attempt to seize her until that point. While I haven't played Crisis Core, from what I've heard of it I've come to believe that Shinra just doesn't know about her while she's dating Zack. Or perhaps they don't become fixated on the Promised Land until the time period after Zack has captured/killed. But this is all unfounded conjecture, and thus would appear to be a definite area where it just doesn't make much sense.

3. Why did Zack not break out from the mako tank earlier - He was definitely in the Mako tank for 4 years, but I think this was because of him actually being in the Mako. It definitely did affect him. After all, that is how those in SOLDIER obtained their power. The difference between him and Cloud was that he successfully retained the power without undue damage to his mental faculties, and it is there where Cloud fails to succeed. And we don't actually know what being trapped in a Mako tank would be like. We don't know what properties exactly Mako has, and what it would do to someone immersed in it. It seems like it induces a coma, and it seems like it took Zack 4 years to shake it off. I'm personally satisfied with that explanation, but I do see how it is a questionable point.

4. How did Cloud manage to survive and defeat Sephiroth where Zack could not in Nibelheim - Well, this one is hard to answer because there are three different renditions of that event. We have the FFVII game, Last Order anime short, and Crisis Core. But, looking at just FFVII alone, we don't actually know how Zack fares against Sephiroth aside from getting overwhelmed in the end. He might have tired Seph just a little. But even if not, Cloud backstabs Sephiroth with the massive buster sword even before Cloud gets impaled by the Masamune. Thus, my argument would be that Sephiroth was almost certainly not on top of his game, allowing Cloud to use his Mako strength to fight the pain of being stabbed by a relatively small weapon (being punctured by the masamune would be a rather small slit through one's body versus a giant gaping hole by the Buster sword) and then to hurl an already injured and potentially tired Sephiroth into the pit below. I don't think Cloud is straight noob compared to Zack when it comes to strength, as the difference between them is their ability to deal with the strain on a mental level, not the physical. Thus, in this situation, a mako soaked idiot could finish the job started by Zack and hurl Sephiroth into the abyss. This seems right to me, but I would definitely be interested in any problem you see in that analysis.

5. What is the deal with Vincent and Chaos - Well, they explain Chaos and Vincent's transformations in FFVII as being the results of mako experiments by Hojo. That seems like a satisfactory explanation to me. Hojo was a sick bastard who did all sorts of shenanigans with mako on test subjects. I don't know what Dirge of Cerberus said about that, but I was totally satisfied with how it was explained in FFVII by itself.

As for the weapons, I know that they were released to kill all life to restore power to the lifestream, but they did seem to have some method behind that. After all, every single one of them seems to beeline for Midgar, and I think that is because they realize that as the biggest threat to the planet (because of its massive and constant drain on the lifestream). They don't recognize Sephiroth because his barrier removes him from their vision, which is why they did not attack him directly. That barrier that Sephiroth creates completely prevents them from doing anything about him. And once it is down, there isn't a single weapon left to do anything about it. The only odd exception is Ultimate Weapon, as it is up to the gamer whether to finish that one off for its loot or not.

A few clarifactions are in order here:

The WEAPONS were NOT designed to kill all life (with the exception of Omega Weapon in FFVII: Dirge of Cerberus, but we're only concentrating on the original game as canon for the time being), but rather they were originally created by the Planet as a last ditch defense system against Jenova. Iflana clearly states this in Gast's video records in his old house in Icicle Inn.

Because the remaining Cetra managed to defeat Jenova and confine her deep within the planet's crust however, the Weapons were no longer required, and remained in stasis, until Cloud gave the Black Materia to Sephiroth, and the resultant summoning of Meteor.

However, it's a little unclear as to why the Weapons started attacking human society rather than Sephiroth. A possibility could be that with all the degradation to the Planet caused by the Mako reactors, plus Jenova cells being implanted in many people, their sense could have become muddled. All they know is the Planet is in danger, and so they must protect it the only way they know how.

Interestingly, at least two of the Weapons (Sapphire and Diamond) directly attack a place where Rufus currently is located (Junon and Midgar respectively), so possibly, the Shinra must be considered a major threat to the Weapons that they must attack them, or rather, their leader. But that's just an assumption on my part.

As for why Aeris was never recaptured, this might have had something to do with Tseng. Once he found out about her whereabouts, he merely kept her under constant surveillance (it even mentions this in Aeris's character description in the manual for FFVII: Crisis Core). The reason for doing this might have been because of Aeris's mixed heritage (only being half-Cetra rather than a full-blooded one, there might have been doubts about the extent of her powers), so the Shinra might have decided to simply try a 'wait and see' approach with her instead of capturing her and holding her as a lab animal.

Or, the fact Tseng never bothered taking her into Shinra custody until the destruction of Sector 7 might have owed a lot to the fact that he secretly had feelings for her (this is clearly stated in game actually that he was attracted to her) - it had nothing to do with Zack's relationship with her, as Crisis Core showed. In fact, Zack never even knew her true identity as a Cetra, because Tseng deliberately kept it a secret from him.

But of course, this is all just personal opinion and assumption so I'm just rambling on here. :)

Yeah, that all makes a lot more sense, Enkidoh.

But, regarding the weapons, we seem to keep forgetting that Sephiroth deliberately erected a barrier with the weapons in mind in order to prevent them from recognizing where he was, which is the reason why they do not attack him. And once the barrier is down, there aren't any left except for Ultimate (maybe) and the Ruby and Emerald weapons which don't really count given their presence as extra content. Other than this point, I agree with your analysis of the facts here.

Yeah, I thought of Tseng with the whole Aeris thing, but at the same time we have to keep in mind that one scene where he displays her to the rest of the team via the helicopter above the Sector 7 pillar, and even smacks her if I remember correctly. I mention that because I don't think Tseng's potential affection by itself would stop Shinra's overall goal of obtaining Aeris. Consequently, it seems more to me that they had her under constant surveillance because they hadn't decided what to do with her yet, and just happened to go into aggressive 'take her' mode once Hojo started calling more of the shots and when Cloud happened to be present in the church at that time. To be honest, it isn't a terribly satisfactory explanation, but I do think that is definitely one of the areas where the plot just doesn't quite make sense, as Dragoncurry pointed out.

Thanks for those clarifications, though. I completely forgot about Gast's video recordings!

Here's a good one-- Rufus obviously loathed Heidegger and Palmer. Why didn't he fire them? Particularly Palmer.

Well, Heidegger was the head of the Shinra's 'Peace Preservation' (their military) so he at least had some use to Rufus.

Palmer on the other hand, was completely useless, being head of their defunct Space Program. He doesn't seem to do anything else in the company other than make stupid faces during board meetings and whine a lot. At least he had finally got given something to do when Rufus decided to use the rocket as a materia missile to destroy Meteor. But he still ended up being surplus to requirements.

In most likely hood though, the Japanese corporate tradition of keeping retrenched employees on the payroll, but moving them into a location where they just simply watch the time, in order to keep their dubious honour, applies with Palmer. But that's a long shot.

Well Rufus comes into power only as you are about to leave Midgar. So, I also imagine that he wants to keep these guys who are in the upper echelons in charge in order to get information from them about managing the company. After all, they were around under his father and even though they appear incompetent, they undoubtedly have a good sense of how Shinra works as a corporation.

As for Palmer in particular, he may have been useless, but I doubt Rufus ever gave him much thought beside him being a pest. After all, Rufus' attention is focused on everything but the space program throughout most of the game, which would explain why he doesn't fire Palmer. He simply wouldn't know about Palmer's uselessness because it isn't his priority to look for it.

And lastly, Darth Vader hated everyone, but this didn't have him executing or firing every commander of every star destroyer he happened across. Sometimes you make use of your underlings even if you privately hate their guts.

P.S. - The Japanese corporate tradition is also a very good argument!

Not getting caught up in this argument since I got tired of it years ago, but I'll snipe it with a pretty definitive hole.

Remember the bit where they're all leaving Midgar and conveniently decide that chasing Sephiroth, who most of the party know next to nothing about and who has done nothing more at that point than kill a guy who had it coming, is the way to save the planet? It's like the writers just had no idea how they could possibly explain Barret coming along, so they just made up some bullshit and hoped all the people playing the game were too young or stupid to notice.

:) Totally right, Prak


I actually got into this argument with some people on another board, but I eventually gave up, because it just isn't worth bothering with. If I wanted to, I could comb over the entire FFVII script with a comb and come up with a bunch of plotholes. But I don't see the point of it. And either way, I still like the game.

Oh, P.S.:


And lastly, Darth Vader hated everyone, but this didn't have him executing or firing every commander of every star destroyer he happened across. Sometimes you make use of your underlings even if you privately hate their guts.
Yes, but Vader had scope over an entire Empire spanning a whole galaxy and rarely had to put up with the continued presence of any of those particular commanders for very long. But if somebody was as annoying to him as Palmer or Heidegger, I think he might have killed him. And Rufus had to put up with both, constantly. However, the other arguments regarding this point are good, though.

Prak - For the most part, I think that observation is right. I even went and looked at that part of the game, and they all seem like they don't know what to do now and will just go pursue Sephiroth because Cloud says, "I have a score to settle with him." Which is bullshit, because at this point Cloud doesn't even have the memory of being stabbed by him, thus making me wonder what 'score' he is talking about.

However, once they get to that next town (Kalm, I think it is), Cloud tells them about how Sephiroth's power is unimaginable, how he wipes out an entire town single handedly, and how he frees Jenova. Now it is pretty obvious at this point at this point in the game that Jenova is a pretty messed up entity that escapes in Shinra tower and receives some further backstory within Cloud's Nibelheim flashback. Also within the flashback, Sephiroth announces to Cloud/Zack how the entire human race are traitors and deserve to be wiped out for betraying whom Sephiroth mistakenly believes to be his people (the Ancients). This, in combination with his obvious power and 'alliance' with Jenova, would distinguish him as a pretty massive threat to the human population of the world, if not "The Planet" itself. Altogether, I think this definitely establishes some validity to their choice in pursuing him/Jenova as a danger, although it is definitely jarring to all of a sudden have the all powerful Shinra Corporation be replaced by this largely unknown character as the main enemy at this point in the game.

In short, you are right that it is a plot hole. But, in my opinion, it is one that is quickly taken care of fifteen minutes later in the game.

Agent0042 - Yeah, I'm not challenging everyone to comb over the plot for holes. I began this thread because I previously had no idea what people were talking about in other threads when they mentioned FF7 as being rife with plot holes, as these statements were never alongside any examples. I'm definitely learning now. And I thank you all for mentioning them, as it helps me understand that FF7's plot isn't immaculate.

As for Darth Vader... lol... yeah, I see your point. Having not played the game for some time, I didn't recall Palmer or Heidegger being around Rufus all the time. But, if they were, then I would definitely understand more the argument for killing them off. However, when it comes down to it, it really doesn't seem like Rufus was the type for spontaneously killing off those beneath him. In fact, I can't think of a single instance when he does that. Also, he seems to have loathed his dad, but never made any attempt to kill him off so he could grab power early (that I know of). He was just quick to take advantage of the opportunity created by Seph/Jenova when it arose.

I didn't say he had to kill them. I just said it seemed to me like he would fire them.

Sorry =)

I thought of Darth Vader and instantly started thinking, "Must kill...".

Not exactly a plot hole, but in the holding cell Barret mentions that the Cetra is a name for the Ancients. Yet when the whole party (after getting Cid) arrives at the Gold Saucer he acts as though he's never heard the name.

Prak - For the most part, I think that observation is right. I even went and looked at that part of the game, and they all seem like they don't know what to do now and will just go pursue Sephiroth because Cloud says, "I have a score to settle with him." Which is bullshit, because at this point Cloud doesn't even have the memory of being stabbed by him, thus making me wonder what 'score' he is talking about.

However, once they get to that next town (Kalm, I think it is), Cloud tells them about how Sephiroth's power is unimaginable, how he wipes out an entire town single handedly, and how he frees Jenova. Now it is pretty obvious at this point at this point in the game that Jenova is a pretty messed up entity that escapes in Shinra tower and receives some further backstory within Cloud's Nibelheim flashback. Also within the flashback, Sephiroth announces to Cloud/Zack how the entire human race are traitors and deserve to be wiped out for betraying whom Sephiroth mistakenly believes to be his people (the Ancients). This, in combination with his obvious power and 'alliance' with Jenova, would distinguish him as a pretty massive threat to the human population of the world, if not "The Planet" itself. Altogether, I think this definitely establishes some validity to their choice in pursuing him/Jenova as a danger, although it is definitely jarring to all of a sudden have the all powerful Shinra Corporation be replaced by this largely unknown character as the main enemy at this point in the game.

In short, you are right that it is a plot hole. But, in my opinion, it is one that is quickly taken care of fifteen minutes later in the game.

The point you're trying to make here can only be considered to resemble anything rational if all pieces of a story are related simultaneously. As it stands, regardless of what happens afterward, the characters arrive at a decision that is based in pure counter-intuitive anti-logic.

An analogy I like to use is that bits like that are staples binding together irreconcilable pages from totally different books.

Prak - What I was trying to do was explain how them choosing to chase Sephiroth was a rational decision, and not entirely a wtf? choice as you portray it to be. I don't believe their choice to pursue him was counter-intuitive or anti-logic, but I do agree that their choice to do so so suddenly after escaping Shinra's grasp was very jarring. Shinra is portrayed as the defining enemy up to this point, making the switch to chasing Sephiroth instead of directly opposing Shinra (somehow) a little unexpected. But, like I mentioned before, I think that they do have a good reason for doing so, and Sephiroth's importance is hinted at with a number of flashbacks and actions throughout their experience in Midgar, making it justified in my eyes, if nothing else.

FinalFlash - Sounds like a Barret brain fart to me, lol.

You're still falling into the same trap of not factoring in the order of events. Sure, all that stuff you mentioned gets talked about in the game, but all of that is still unknown to at least the majority of the characters when they still somehow come to the conclusion that Sephiroth takes priority. It's just as I said; Squaresoft was obviously just hoping their target audience was young and stupid enough to look at it exactly as you are now. And to be fair, had I played it when I was a teenager, I might have fallen into that trap myself, as all teenagers are inherently retarded.

Anyway, FF7 is a very boring conversation topic to me and I'm done harping on how awful it is. I'd be more into it if you met me three years ago.

Yeah, you are right. I was just trying to explain that, while their initial decision to chase Sephiroth is almost completely unfounded, they discover all the information I explained in my previous previous post through Cloud's explanation of the Nibelheim flashback, which highlights why he is a very considerable threat (although nobody knows at the time just how much of a threat to the entire planet he is). Cloud knows all about why Sephy is a threat and explains that to the rest of the team, making their decision to chase him more rational.

But anyways, my back-and-forth with you is just me doing my best to gloss over what is definitely a plot hole (although I argue that it is short lived) that you definitively highlight. You win. You got me ;)

Wait a sec. In examining the moment more closely... Barret agrees to come along, but then again, Barret isn't always portrayed as the brightest bulb in the chandelier. Remember what we said earlier about him acting like he didn't know what the Cetra was, when he had actually mentioned them before. And Barret seems like a pretty easygoing guy-- if Cloud says that going after Sephiroth will help, I think that maybe he'd tag along with him at least for a bit until he heard more, which he did. Plus they'd just been, well, pretty well run down, so getting out of town for a while rather made sense.

Once Barret goes along with the idea, Tifa is pretty much automatically onboard. And Aeris wants to leave anyway to find out more about the Cetra. As for Red XIII, he specifically says he wants to go home and is coming with the group as far as that point.


I'm not saying that there aren't plotholes in the game, but I'm actually no longer convinced this is a big one.

Agent - Yeah, I've also not been convinced this is such a major plot hole, which is what I've been trying to explain and defend. But, while your argument makes sense, Agent, I have to agree with Prak in the fact that, at this point in the game, it suddenly seems like the people writing the script have no idea what to do with the characters anymore, and sort of lamely have them all head in Sephiroth's direction simply because they don't know what else to do. If you read the script of what the characters say right after they get out of Midgar (I have a script handy given my little writing occupation), they sort of lamely say that they'll go ahead and all pursue Sephiroth without argument based on Cloud simply saying that 'he has a score to settle' with him.

So, although your argument regarding their rationale for following Cloud and therefore pursuing Sephiroth is a good one, the way it is presented in the game definitely makes you say, "Wait, what?" when they choose to pursue him after the entire previous portion of the game presenting Shinra as the enemy. Like you, I don't think this is a major plot hole, but it is definitely not a terribly good moment in the FF7 story and game.

Well, you have a point, but again, it's only Barret who says, "Yeah, let's go get Sephiroth." Tifa doesn't really say anything, Aeris says she wants to learn about the Cetra and Red wants to go home.

And not to nitpick, but what you say makes it sound even more irrational that they all go with Cloud to pursue Sephiroth. Aeris and Red sound like they don't even care (they have other objectives), Tifa we can assume will just follow Cloud wherever he goes, and Barret is just kinda dumb. Not a good situation.

Characters biting their tong even when it makes no sense for them to do so is a big problem for the series, and probably reached its zenith in Final Fantasy VIII when Irvine neglects to mention to the rest of the cast that they all grew up together, and their target for the upcoming assassination mission just happens to be the person who raised them. My theory is that scenario writer Kazushige Nojima just happens to be the sort of jerk who purposely leaves out important details about his life just so that when queried about it later he can contend that they "didn't ask".

okay, im going to say a few glaring plot holes, just to spark up debate again. Though i feel like im probably going to walk into a few traps here, what the hell, i'll still get my point across.

Genesis, plot hole. Angeal, Plot hole. Hollander, Plot hole (simply because hojo and gast are recognized throughout the game as the main scientists for using jenova cells)
Professor Gast is actually mentioned very little in crisis core or last order, whereas in FFVII (if i recall correctly) when sephiroth finds the pods of monsters, he says something like "very good hojo, but you'll never amount to Professor Gast".

Another plot hole is, hojo said in crisis core, that anything unknown discovered was classed as an ancient, referring to Jenova, yet not one of the hundreds of books or reports within the mansion or Shinra HQ disregarded this, Sephiroth still apparently believed he was an ancient. Which is a huge cause of confusion.

Ifalna was captured when Gast was killed by Hojo, now, what happened to her when she was captured? I do honestly believe that Square Enix will now come out with an evil ancient or tell the fans that Sephiroth was infact an ancient through genetic experiments with Ifalnas blood, or somehow it will come back to haunt us.

Theirs a five year gap between Nibelheim and FFVII as we know, four years of that (give or take a few months) was zack and cloud in a tube. They have yet ANOTHER huge gap to fill in, some of that will be for before crisis story, but theirs alot of other things going on that should conflict or tie in.

Heres the big contradiction, even if its a little pitiful.
In FFVII, cloud is clearly wearing a purple soldier uniform, the same one given to him by Zack. In crisis core, he gives him a black one. However, think back to luxerre and Kunsel, Second Class Soldiers wearing....purple.

Actually i do have a question, Angeal is supposed to be the perfect spawn of Jenova, able to absorb and pass on genetic traits to and from others. However, could Jenova really pass on her traits without surgery?
And why is it that Lucrecia was immune to degredation for so long?

Did vincent die and chaos rebirthed him?
Did cloud and zack die, and S cells and makou revive them?

Before i get alot of cloud fanboys rip my head off, just remember what happened to them both, could he really survive that? as for zack fanboys, watch last order, could he really survive that?

A question or contradiction if you will, Why didnt the turks intervene when the shinra army found Zack? i dont think itd be that hard to notice world war 3 or radio transmissions. The turks still hold alot of power, or they are meant to, in FFVII you see them hold alot of sway among the infantry units.

While all those points are interesting, I have to say that I've no idea how to respond to many of them as most of them deal with events in Crisis Core and Dirge of Cerberus, which is not what I'm trying to reconcile here. My objective with this thread was to ask for plot holes within the Final Fantasy VII game by itself. I would be surprised if there weren't plot holes between different games, as they tend to deal with very new or drastically altered information. I would be interested to see if someone else would be willing to assess and defend against those points though! I've played neither of the games, so I cannot.

Here are my answers to some of your other points though:

Ifalna's captivity: I wouldn't call this a plot hole, as you don't have to explain what happens in every moment mentioned in a story for it to run smoothly. We know that she was experimented upon and that they undoubtedly performed many tests, allowing them to learn more about the Cetra and what they were capable of. Calling this a plot hole would be similar to calling the war with Wutai a giant plot hole because we don't actually see any of it in the game.

The events in between Nibelheim and FFVII: This is very similar. All we really need to know is that they were stuck in tubes and experimented upon. This allowed Shinra to learn more about their own SOLDIER program and what made Zack a success versus Cloud as a failure. This could also contribute to what I see as their increased strength after escaping, as we know Cloud during Nibelheim was relatively weak. They probably injected more mako in him in this time, which explains why Cloud is almost a vegetable during their escape. In any case, I don't see why you consider this a plot hole as we know they were stuck in a tube all this time. We don't need to know what happened every day.

Sorry if my assessment of those 'holes' is a trifle harsh, but I think it is accurate. Let me know if you disagree.

Actually Zack was far weaker as he stated on several occasions on crisis core.

A hole counts for any amount of time where their could be alot of story added to the existing part, and technically if you want to talk about nibelheim, you need to watch last order and play crisis core, FFVII said absolutely nothing about nibelheim except that it happened. Where it happened also differs, as does the size of the reactor itself. FFCC zack falls forever, in last order, they fight in the pipes above.

Ifalnas capture is quite a hole, anything can happen, they can introduce an entirely new story simply because ifalnas blood and genes were obtained when she was captured. That one just like Genesis, can be a hole if it were ever revisited by SE.

And if you dont want to go into FFVII story, the soldier colours thing, that is however in the FFVII tech demo. Cloud wears black.

okay probably not a plot hole, but destroys the entire story. Technological advancements throughout the games. i think we all know what im talking about.
And i still say, Mako was supposed to be a metaphor for oil, before Advent children came along that is -_-'

I have no idea what Zack or anyone said in Crisis Core, as I haven't played it.

Your definition of plot hole seems far too broad to me. Take Cloud's flashbacks and memories of the past, for example. By your definition, the fact that the story does not include every single small event of his childhood and time before Nibelheim means that this omission is a massive gaping plot hole. After all, his childhood must undoubtedly contribute to the story and his growth as a character, and the fact that it is hardly represented means that these are gargantuan plot holes.

But when it comes down to it, it isn't. We don't have to hear about everything Cloud did before the events of FFVII because it isn't relevant. Just like we don't have to hear about everything that happened to Ifalna during her captivity because it isn't relevant to the overarching story. This also applies to when Zack and Cloud were in the tubes. Does it truly matter that we don't get to see what happened during those years they were held within them. Not really. It was probably pretty boring. The fact that events happen behind the scenes don't make the omission of what exactly happened a plot hole.

As for what you say about Nibelheim... No. I don't have to watch Last Order and play Crisis Core before I can talk about those events because they are outlined quite thoroughly within FF7 itself. I know of those other depictions, and each are different as it has different developers giving their own impressions of what happened. In any case, I am just talking about FF7 alone in this thread, making all the other games and movies irrelevant from my point of view. Once again, we don't have to actually see Zack get his ass kicked by Sephiroth to know that it happened. The fact that we do not see the battle in FF7 does not make it a plot hole.

As for your statement about the different colors of uniform Cloud wears in the different games, I did not address it because I haven't played those other games. If it is different, then the developers probably didn't look too closely at the original FF7 material. Or, more likely, they just didn't care. It isn't a huge issue.

I'm not too sure Mako is a metaphor for oil. If we look at it closely, that doesn't seem probable. Mako is derived from the lifestream, which is the energy of the planet. Oil is oil, and if we used up all the oil in the world, I don't think it would cause the earth to shrivel up and fall apart. In Bugenhagen's conservatory we see that draining the planet of lifestream causes exactly that. Therefore my opinion is that, like most FFVII games, I think Mako's presence in the story simply follows the same trend of the other Final Fantasy stories: people need to stand up to those who misuse or abuse what the earth gives us. Pollution and waste is bad.