Pol Wespol
08-29-2007, 03:23 PM
Sometimes, it almost feels like these guys make lists like this on purpose just to cause some sort of negative reaction. I will find it hard to believe that anyone can agree fully with this list...
10. Metroid
9. Blades of Steel
8. Wizards & Warriors
7. Dr. Mario
6. Punch-Out!!
5. Shadowgate
4. Contra
3. The Legend of Zelda
2. Castlevania
1. Super Mario Bros
http://games.ign.com/articles/811/811667p1.html
I'll just mention as many things as I can on why this list is just horrible.
1. Ninja Gaiden - Should be #1. IMHO, it was so far above and beyond anything else that was around at the time, and nothing after it surpassed it. It made their "honorable mention" list, but should have AT LEAST made this list...
2. Dragon Quest (Warrior) IV - This one didn't even make the "honorable mention" list. I find it almost insulting that this game's soundtrack didn't make the list. This is easily in my top 3, and one of my personal favorites of all time...
3. Mega Man III - OK, Mega Man II was the better GAME overall, but III had the best soundtrack. So, not only did they give Mega Man II an "honorable mention," which is just wrong already, but they gave it to the wrong Mega Man. Regardless of which one is considered the better soundtrack, both of them could have (and at least one of them should have) been on this list...
4. Final Fantasy - Not sure if they just forgot about this one. I don't see how you forget Final Fantasy's soundtrack. Of all the Final Fantasy pieces ever composed, Matoya's Cave is still my favorite of all time...
Their top 3 isn't all that bad, and if there is ONE really positive thing I can say about this list, it's that I'm glad they made sure Shadowgate was on the list. That game's soundtrack deserves to be in any top 10 list IMO, not just 8-bit...
Other's thoughts?
10. Metroid
9. Blades of Steel
8. Wizards & Warriors
7. Dr. Mario
6. Punch-Out!!
5. Shadowgate
4. Contra
3. The Legend of Zelda
2. Castlevania
1. Super Mario Bros
http://games.ign.com/articles/811/811667p1.html
I'll just mention as many things as I can on why this list is just horrible.
1. Ninja Gaiden - Should be #1. IMHO, it was so far above and beyond anything else that was around at the time, and nothing after it surpassed it. It made their "honorable mention" list, but should have AT LEAST made this list...
2. Dragon Quest (Warrior) IV - This one didn't even make the "honorable mention" list. I find it almost insulting that this game's soundtrack didn't make the list. This is easily in my top 3, and one of my personal favorites of all time...
3. Mega Man III - OK, Mega Man II was the better GAME overall, but III had the best soundtrack. So, not only did they give Mega Man II an "honorable mention," which is just wrong already, but they gave it to the wrong Mega Man. Regardless of which one is considered the better soundtrack, both of them could have (and at least one of them should have) been on this list...
4. Final Fantasy - Not sure if they just forgot about this one. I don't see how you forget Final Fantasy's soundtrack. Of all the Final Fantasy pieces ever composed, Matoya's Cave is still my favorite of all time...
Their top 3 isn't all that bad, and if there is ONE really positive thing I can say about this list, it's that I'm glad they made sure Shadowgate was on the list. That game's soundtrack deserves to be in any top 10 list IMO, not just 8-bit...
Other's thoughts?