Alright, question. Is it ever explicitly stated, be it in game or in one of the Ultimania guides, how long a Calm lasts for? The only one I've heard of was Gandof's calm, which lasted for less than a year.

I heard it was 10 years. o_O

Braska's pilgrimage was 10 years ago, right?

The Calm always lasts for 10 years and then another cicle begins maybe the power of the Final Aeon might add some more or less time...

I heard it was 10 years. o_O

Braska's pilgrimage was 10 years ago, right?

True, but that implies that Sin only publicly reappeared at the very minute the game commences, does it not?


The Calm always lasts for 10 years and then another cicle begins maybe the power of the Final Aeon might add some more or less time...

Where'd you get that info from?

It's 10 years everytime...

It says so in the game.

And 10 years is not exactly 10*365.

True, but that implies that Sin only publicly reappeared at the very minute the game commences, does it not?



Where'd you get that info from?

Well the 10 year part is stated in the game but i think that after Yunalesca Sin only appeared again some years after not in the ten year period.

It's nothing like 10 years. If it was 10 years, then why did Lulu and Wakka have a history of being guardians? If there was no Sin, there would be no need for a Summoner for them to guard.

The ultimania also state that Yuna was in training to be a Summoner for 2 years prior to the game (which is why Lulu and Wakka went off to be guardians so they had some experiance prior to being Yuna's guardian).

Chappu was also killed the previous year, by Sin.

Taking note of all these facts only leads to one conclusion, Sin has been around for quite a while before the game, so the idea of a ten year calm is nonsense.

Also, the ultimania give a rough estimate that the calms last only a year, give or take a few months...

10 years is indeed stated in the game, but its in no way in the appropriate context to assume that there was no Sin for the last decade. i.e. Yuna saying her dad defeated Sin 10 years ago to bring the Calm is not the same as Yuna saying her dad defeated Sin 10 years ago and have lived in a Calm ever since.

Also, I would like to know Jimmy! how you managed to deduce that Sin appeared after a ten year period after being beaten by Yunalesca?